Category: Political Theory
-
Locke’s Concept of Revolution
Locke’s state is limited and constitutional. It exercises power based on the consent of the people as a trust implied in the social contract. Government is bound by the terms of the contract to safeguard and protect the natural rights—right to life liberty and property, for which it has been instituted. This means, legitimacy of…
-
Aristotle’s Concept of Revolution
Aristotle’s analysis and description of 158 constitutions of Greek city-states suggested that these constitutions changed periodically and the changes occurred as cyclical alterations. Aristotle observed that these alterations followed a pattern of transformation, which reflected change in the nature of the constitution, e.g., from monarchy-aristocracy-democracy to tyrann–oligarch–mobocracy. While the first set represents ‘pure’ forms of constitution, the second set…
-
Resistance and Revolution
Resistance and Revolution are manifestations of the limit of political obligation and reflects a state of affairs when citizens acquire a right to resist and disobey the state. Most of the political resistance could be of intra-systemic while revolution is extra-systemic and seeks extra legal solution. A distinction between revolution and other forms of resistance…
-
Political Obligation Under Post-renaissance European Political Thought
Machiavelli and Raison d’etat as basis of political obligation: Machiavelli provides the keyhole to peep into the post-Renaissance political theory and why does the state require its subject to pay obedience. In his Prince (1532), Machiavelli put forth the justification that the interest or the end of the state, which is acquisition and maintenance of power, is prime…
-
Political Obligation During the Colonial Rule in India
The British rule in India was characterized, amongst others, by: (i) feudal relations—zamindari, mahalwari and ryotwari based on how land right was granted to the people, in individual capacity or as village, and how revenue collection is patterned, and (ii) political relation—subjects bearing the laws, codes and regulations framed by the foreign rule. There was no political participation…
-
Political Obligation in Indian Political Thought
The theory of divine origin is found in the Manusmriti,20 Shantiparvan of Mahabharata and in Kautilaya’s Arthásastra. These ancient texts have talked about political and moral obligations of the subjects by implying the divine origin of rulers. L. N. Rangarajan, in his translation of Kautilaya’s Arthdsastra, states that while Dharmashastras are addressed to the individual, teaching him his dharma and regard deviations as sin, ‘the Arthashastras are addressed to…
-
Political Obligation Under Islamic Injunctions
Unlike the Christian tradition (the church-state controversy), in Islamic tradition, the temporal and the spiritual are not dichotomized. The state and political obligation are not outside the Quranic vision. As Karen Armstrong, who has written several books on religions, in her Islam: A Short History, says, ‘A Muslim had to redeem history, and that meant that…
-
Political Obligation Under Feudal Europe
Added to this duality of political and religious obligations, feudal Europe witnessed diffusion and dilution of even political obligation. Feudalism is characterized by diffusion of power, fixed social hierarchies and a rigid pattern of obligations and services. This means that unlike sovereignty of the nation-state, the feudal society had no centrally located power, no concept…
-
Political Obligation versus Christian Obligation
With the emergence of Christianity and decline of the Roman period, the issue of political obligation came to be debated from political as well as religious angles; what obligation a Christian bears to a king. The dictum that was put before the people appeared to be what Jesus had said and St. Paul had dutifully…
-
Political Obligation During the Roman Period
Greek political theory celebrated the polis but did not differentiate society from the State. Polis was all-encompassing and lack of distinction between the State and society meant lack of any distinction between the rights of individuals and authority of the polis. The two were merged and political obligation was as much a matter of civic…