Category: Political Theory

  • Is the working class struggling for rights or revolution?

    Under the capitalist system there is inequality of rights as well as alienation. This be so, the Marxian perspective seeks the end of both. But it is also true that neither is possible under the capitalist system. As a result, revolutionary overthrow of the capitalist system is the slogan that comes into play. Till that happens, we may ask…

  • Critique of bourgeois rights

    In his Economic and Philosophical Manuscript (1844), Marx says ‘Man is a species-being … also because he treats himself as the actual, living species; because he treats himself as a universal and therefore a free being.’90 The import of this idea of Marx is that human being is, what John Plamenatz in his Karl Marx’s Philosophy of Man says, a ‘self-creating being’.91 This…

  • Marxian Perspective on Rights

    It is understood that Marx neither concentrated on formulation of a theory of state nor of rights. Rights, as claims of individuals to be recognized by the state or the society, need special scrutiny if we have to construct any Marxian position on rights. Unlike the Liberal framework, which is based on individual as the…

  • Theories of human rights

    Based on the grounds of human rights and the specific challenges to the universality claim of human rights, we can list the perspectives or theories of human rights as follows:

  • Debate on ‘universal’ versus ‘value specific’ rights and its implications

    Insistence on universality of the contents of human rights and their being applicable to all, irrespective of social, cultural and religious context, has led to controversy. Firstly, the evolution of human rights in terms of content has led to the debate on values and culture specific rights versus universal rights. Secondly, there may be contradiction…

  • Content and scope of human rights

    Human rights include various types of rights, ranging from liberal or ‘bourgeois’ rights to social and economic rights to cultural and religious and also civil and political rights. Chris Brown has identified three generations of rights as part of evolution of content of human rights.81 These are: Human rights appear to contain three generation of rights—civil…

  • Consequences of human rights arguments

    It appears that human rights are treated as part of natural rights or moral entitlements that inhere in the very existence of human beings, right from the stage of conceiving to death. Arguments with respect to the scope of the human right have, for example, included right of an unborn child and right of a…

  • Grounds of human rights

    It is understood that the human rights trace their root from the natural rights. Andrew Heywood maintains that ‘the idea of human rights developed out of the ‘‘natural rights’’ theories …’77 Natural rights such as right to ‘life, liberty and property’ (Locke) or right to ‘life, liberty and pursuit of happiness’ (Thomas Jefferson, American Declaration of Independence) or…

  • Theory of Human Rights

    The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966 states that human rights derive from the inherent dignity of the human person.76 Human rights are considered by most societies to belonging automatically to everyone; as if they are given as part of human life. This may include freedom, justice, equality, life with dignity, etc. Does this mean that human…

  • Critical evaluation

    Any right that is in consonance with public welfare is reasonable. Public welfare subsumes the welfare of each individual as well. From this perspective, social welfare seems to be an appropriate ground for claiming rights. But then, we are faced with a problem. How do we determine public welfare? If Bentham’s thesis of greatest happiness of…